My wonderful second cousin, the daughter of my cousin who I think becomes my second cousin, moved from close to me to Connecticut over a year ago. Recently, I received emails that she’d posted pictures of her new home and her wonderful children on her Facebook page. I was not given access to them without signing onto Facebook, which didn’t appeal to me but whatever …. After the third time when her pictures were withheld from me without joining, I joined.
It was good to see her pictures.
Many of my real time friends are on Facebook so I added them as my Facebook friends, and often their friends and my real life acquaintances who I like but don’t talk to all that much, and some people whose first names I recognized but ended up not being who I thought they were.
For the record, gods bless Facebook and all those who enjoy it and make use of it for their reasons.
I never liked it. I dislike parties, rooms full of people, small talk, and it felt like that to me.
What I disliked the most was the weird function where someone announces that “(Their Name Here) likes this.” Banal much? Why does anyone even mention such a lukewarm opinion. I don’t mean to attack those who do, but why? Why? WHY? If one has nothing to say about it, why mention such a bland, formatted by the site liking of it. I imagine going to see a movie or show with friends and after it we went out for a bite and some of us said, “I liked it,” while others said nothing at all.
Banality seems the FB norm to me. Why have your life published to everyone at the same time as the same thing to each of your friends and family and their whomevers? I think I have different relationships with each of the people I know, sharing experiences based on things we’ve shared, not generic information about all of us to everybody. I say this on this Blog to whomever stumbles onto it. Hypocrite much?
I disliked and mostly ignored Facebook. Again, gods bless those who find it useful and friendly. And I honor that my artist friends get to post information about where they’ll be showing their art. That makes sense to me, as a fresh new way to share with those who might be interested in what’s out there that isn’t being mentioned elsewhere.
A dear, wonderful friend I love and respect, who I’ll call Macy, put up a video on her Facebook page of NY Senator Diane Savino supporting gay marriage. When I saw Macy live and in person, she encouraged me to watch it two different times, so I signed onto her on Facebook and watched. It’s the best … it’s not an argument, just simplicity and acceptance and fairness articulated.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q08Ggd-OlCM
I was moved, so I commented to her on her Facebook page: Thank you, married lady, for encouraging this homo, who’s shared a criminal marriage with another homo for 29 and 1/2 years, to watch this brilliant, simple (in the best way), clear as a bell woman’s common sense. We have living wills making each other each other’s legal guardians, but the simple truth is we are married, no matter what the government and all the Gods in all the Heavens think of it. It never occurred to me until people started making laws that said, “You aren’t married,” to insist, “Yes, we are.” The issue educated me about the clear fact of our marriage. 29 and 1/2 years into it, we are as married as any married couple anywhere ever. Traditional marriage, where fathers sold their daughters to fathers with sons, where 25 desperate women try to hook up with one guy on a TV show, and vice versa, needs to catch up with us. Let us determine who’s married and who isn’t, if you want to be fair. For the record, Senator Steven and Junior Senator Chris have determined that you U.S. citizens Macy and Winston seem to be very happily married so get to remain married thus far. We will continue to observe and deliberate.
After that, I wrote something else: Sorry to say even more, but I left out that I like to sing to Chris, “I love you more today than yesterday, but not as much as tomorrow, (I say today, and I hope it stays true.)” Who knows about tomorrow, but today I love him more than yesterday and he says it to me. Besides demanding so-called marriage, I love him up, up to the sky.
Later, I sent an email of this info the my friend, Macy, unsure when/if she’d notice on FB. She emailed me back.
“Yeah, you might want to limit your FB comments to a sentence or two.
But it’s all good. Just FYI, whenever you comment on a post, anyone who’s commented on the post before you or anyone who’s hit “like” on that post will get an email with your comment. The people who’d commented before you are all cool, so no worries, but just so you know.
”
Huh? A sentence or two? And multiple smiley faces? Have we never met? The video that was shared with me moved me, touched on my life, and inspired comment that was less minimal than “FunkWillBeInIt liked this.”
This was my Facebook breaking point, realizing it’s not like friendships for me, not about relationships where the conversations are personal, where I was discouraged to be more than a sentence of two.
So I deactivated Facebook and wrote to Macy that I did: I get it, but don’t only allow me to see what you encourage me to see inside your FB community if the real person I am might comment with so much more than “FunkWillBeInIt likes it.”
In future, if you think there’s a website I might appreciate, send it to me personally. I know it might take 10 seconds of your time, but I only joined FB to see pictures my cousin’s daughter’s children that were only posted there.
Limiting my ideas to a sentence or two eats shit to me.
I want to express my thoughts as they exist, and FB is not the place for that. I don’t mean to burden strangers with my unwelcome thoughts and feelings.
As laws may not determine my marriage, FB will not limit me to a sentence or two.
Anyone who wants to can ignore whatever I have to say, and no reason to burden strangers with that.
I’m not in any way hostile, just confused and uncomfortable with FB every step of the way.
Youz are a complete joy in my life.
Chris watched the NY Senator and fell in love with her as well.
She was so worth listening to, inspiring and brilliant and simple in the best way.
I would not have heard her if not for you, so thank you to high heaven.
Good news. Since I dislike the FB experience I’ve deactivated my account, which was a struggle discovering how to do that.
FB sucks one in and will not easily let go. Searching for “cancel” or “close” didn’t find anything, so I had to stumble upon “deactivate” as it is so much like the Terminator.
In future, if you want me to see what you think I might find interesting, you’ll have to send it to me as if I was an individual.
This has been useful clarity for me.
I don’t belong in the FB mob.
And I respect you and most of the peeps I know and love and honor who do.
From now on, I will remain silent.
Shhhhhhh,
FunkWillBeInIt”
Reading it now, it does come off as a bit harsh, I shamefully admit. It wasn’t meant to. I’m not harsh about Macy, not about her saying anything to me, not even about the much beloved Facebook. I sound harsh because it was an experience that left me confused and cranky. It was also fun, to explore it and find I disliked it. It wasn’t quite camp. like, say, Sarah Palin, but almost. It was a silly hoot.
Macy wrote back: OK, you’ve way overreacted here to what I said, if you deactivated your account because of my response to your email. I would never give you a maximum of sentences that you’re allowed to write, and people certainly write more than 2, there’s no rule. When I said “1 or 2″ with a smiley face after it, I was making light of how unusually long your comment was compared to what you might normally see, that’s all. And I was only letting you know about the email sent to people thing in case you didn’t know and cared… I don’t know how much you know yet about how it works, so was trying to help.
Seems a bit dramatic to cancel your account as I think you’d have been a fun person to have on FB, whether they’d have been long or short comments that you made. And it’s not like you join FB and you never can send stuff in an email again, you can certainly still do both. You might have found both outlets valuable in their own ways. But it’s, of course, all up to you.
I wrote back to Macy: I disliked everything about it. Your comment was just the straw that helped me realize my camel’s back was broken.
I’m delightedly not dramatic about removing myself from it.
I’m not being critical of it … well, iI guess I am, but not anymore now that I’ve shed it. I was sneering the “(your name here) likes this” aspect of it yesterday, wondering the value of that.
is all good!
peace and love.
I then emailed to other friends on it: Since I was disliking Facebook every step of the experience, and then I’d posted a paragraph and was advised to keep it down to a sentence or two, I deactivated my account. Being a part of the mob makes me feel like I’m a part of a mob. From now on, if you want to share your ideas with me, you’ll have to pretend I’m an individual and send it as an email like we did in 1980. Sorry if being an email friend instead of a Facebook friend takes 10 more seconds out of your day. Or not. I’m happy finding my personal Jesus.
Friends wrote back:
Wow, I really hate it too—it’s not communication, it’s broadcasting—everyone in their own personal reality tv shows. I started it for business reasons but find myself not using it and not wanting to use my friends for business reasons.
gol! you threw the baby out with the bath water but i understand. there will be other opportunities to be 21st Century Steven without having to become a realtor.
(Wondering where you were typing that you got that message.)
how are you going to know now when someone’s making a sandwich or wishing that it wasn’t raining?!? I fear you’re going to be dangerously cut off!
It is true, now you will truly be left out… Just how WILL you know when someone makes a yummy sandwich. You will miss it when I shovel my driveway or make disparaging comments about my husband!
Oh well….. first we lost your witty blog (I enjoyed it very much) and now the facebook community/cult loses you…
It is a sad sad day…
p.s. This ain’t exactly on topic, but I saw it while I writing the above and it amused me. I saw it on Time Magazine’s Best of Everything as one of the 10 Top Late Night Jokes.
“Twitter went down today. If only there was some short, shallow, self-indulgent way to express my horror.” – Stephen Colbert http://www.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1945379_1945913_1945903,00.html#ixzz0ZJzxXASi